Visualizations
Geographical Distribution of Composers by Country
Both of these visualizations show where composers whose pieces have been played in Junior or Senior solo recitals have come from.
The above map shows how that distribution has changed over time with dark gray countries being unrepresented in the given year, light blue indicating a low number of pieces played, and dark blue representing a high number of pieces played.
In 2018, 42 pieces were played by composers born in the United states, the highest count of pieces played from any one country in a given year across the dataset.
If we look to the right, we can more easily see the number of times pieces pieces from each country have been played from 1933 to 2026. Germany is easily in the lead, which makes sense when considering the birth place of some of the Western World's most famous composers.
Continents
Here it's easy to see just how many pieces come from the Western World. Over 75% of pieces come from European countries alone, roughly 18% from North America (most of which are from the United States), which means that pieces from anywhere else on Earth make up less than 7% of the total number of pieces played.
A closer look
Because Europe takes up such a large portion of the total number of pieces played, we thought it would be interesting to see, within Europe specifically, which countries are better represented.
Surprising no one, Germany is taking up almost a third of the pie chart. Germany and France together make up about half, which we found very interesting. We knew they were among the most represented places, but we didn't realize how much they dominated the other European countries.
Where do the other composers come from? As we can see in the graph to the left, most non-European composers come from the United States, which makes up over three-fourths of the pie chart.
The second most represented country is China, which was mildly surprising given how recent its first appearance in our dataset was. Then again, this is most likely due to the advent of the Carleton Chinese Music Ensemble in 2005, which introduced Chinese music to a broader range of Carleton students.
Without the frontrunners in the mix, it's easy to see which underrepresented countries are present. China and Brazil together make up about half of the pie chart, which isn't too surprising given the map results and the earlier pie charts. Except for Canada, the next five countries after China are all in South America. We don't know exactly why this is, but it is interesting.
Instruments
The instruments that showed the most diversity were also the most popular and well-known overall, such as the violin and piano, which doesn't necessarily mean that people who play those instruments are willing to look at a wider range of songs, just that we have more data of them doing so because we have more data about them in general.
However, looking at the chart on the right, there are clearer patterns for specific countries, such as vocal pieces being the largest type of music from Austria, Italy, and the United Kingdom. We were also expecting to see far more piano and organ pieces coming out of Germany and Austria, as some of our most popular piano/keyboard composers came out of these countries, but voice still holds the majority in both of them.
Composers and Their Pieces
While we didn't find much difference between the overall data and the data of unique pieces chosen (the graph on the right), we found a significant difference between the overall data and the data about unique composers. The amount of unique German composers is much lower than the amount of German songs played, which makes sense considering that some of the most prominent classical composers, such as J. S. Bach, are German. These composers also wrote a lot of songs, which meant that Carleton students had a lot to choose from and overlapped very little, if at all.
So... where's the diversity?
After analyzing our data and looking at these visualizations, we found that the birth place of composers starts becoming more diverse after 2000. Take a look below to see a decade-by-decade progression.